Responsibilities of educated Muslims 15

  The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

Since 1947, India has become play ground of two evil factors :

1. Conspiracies by Hinduttava elements

2. Muslim orthodoxy and fanaticism

Both are reinforcing each other but both factors may make both communities modern and enlightened too.

The above two evil tendencies were allowed to flourish by Congress governments from 1947 to 2013 and now we are witnessing its evil effects.

How country like India – a country having different section of people on basis of religion, caste, language and region, should have been run?

All right thinking people should think on it and should also see how to maintain rule of their party, rule of one family and for Sawarn supremacy and of some northern parts, the  so called champions of democracy, secularism, national integration  and socialism betrayed their avowed higher values. The emerging young generation should stand for integration, socialism and secularism.

National anthem, national song and Tricolour were made centre of our national pride and love. National song declaring worship of mother – the country presented as mother is perhaps against human reason. Many modern people don’t subscribe to medieval version of worship and in its place there are feelings of love and service that should have been avowed.

Then concept of mother is again biased and perhaps vestige of matriarchy prevalent in some parts of ancient India and developed into worship of Kali and Durga, and that was transformed into icon of Bharat Mata during struggle against British rule under leadership of leaders belonging to Bengal.

In the lines of National anthem ‘ jan gan man adhinayak, Bharat bhagya vidhata ‘ here the words adhinayak and bhagya vidhata’ refer to whom ? To British governor general ? It appears that in hurry to grab power the political leaders agreed to Partition and to make national icons hurriedly. From the history, Buddha, Mahavir, Kabir and Nanak should have been chosen as  our teacher and , Ashok, Harsh and Akbar should have been chosen as right rulers. And perhaps those from history of Kashmir, Punjab, Assam, Northeast, Central India and South were not better known and we need to search those teachers and rulers who preached and practiced welfare of all and accord them right status and reject those from myths, epics and those who were unjust.

Then education should have been made uniform and compulsory and religion should have been made private affair without use of loud speakers in religious places and gatherings and limited one or two processions of different religions had been allowed. The education should have aimed to develop human personality with values of human reason, love, brotherhood, democracy, secularism and socialism. There was no sense in allowing religious and communal organizations to grow poisonous weed.

Further seeds of disintegration were sown by linguistic re-charting of map of India.  Perhaps the aim was to prop up local satraps with central help and no other party except Congress had enough funds for that purpose.

Very importantly, the caste should have been pushed back by everyone keeping his personal name, his/ her  mother’s name and lastly his/ her father’s name – no place for caste name.

Responsibilities of educated Muslims 14

 The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

Since 1947, India has become play ground of two evil factors :

1. Conspiracies by Hinduttava elements

2. Muslim orthodoxy and fanaticism

Both are reinforcing each other but both factors may make both communities modern and enlightened too.

Thus Hinduttava was taking shape from 1803 onwards when British took steps against inhuman practices and English educated Aryan elite started opposing these British actions.\

1. BG Tilak started his career as opponent of health measures to control plague and then transformed into nationalist leader.

2. Ishwar Chandra Vidhyasagar appealed the British to keep education confined to Bhadrlog. It means to exclude Backwards and Oppressed from Universal Education.

3. MK Gandhi supported unjust caste system and opposed compulsory education.

 M.K. Gandhi in his Hind Swaraj or Indian Home Rule, writes in 1909, “The ordinary meaning of education is knowledge of letters. To teach boys reading, writing and arithmetic is called primary education. A peasant earns his bread honestly. He has ordinary knowledge of the world. But he cannot write his own name. What do you propose to do by giving him a knowledge of letters? Will you add an inch to his happiness?....it is not necessary to make this education compulsory. Our ancient school system is enough..... We consider your modern school to be useless.” 

Then MK Gandhi became messiah of Untouchables and became Father of Nation. We should ask him can a farmer get loan or get his crop insured safely without knowledge of letters?

Ishwar Chandra Vidhyasagar and M.K. Gandhi were persons whom I understood as most enlightened persons of previous generation in my childhood.

I want to stress that enlightenment, secularism, socialism, Marxism  and democracy are just mask in modern times and underneath each mask you will find a manuvadi wolf.

4. Manu Smriti is available on Internet Sacred Archives.

5. The writings of  MS Golwalkar, RSS Ideologue, are on the website  http://www.golwalkarguruji.org/   and show how he starts from modern values and gradually brings credulous people to Indian version of Nazism.

Responsibilities of educated Muslims 13

  The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

Since 1947, India has become play ground of two evil factors :

1. Conspiracies by Hinduttava elements

2. Muslim orthodoxy and fanaticism

Both are reinforcing each other but both factors may make both communities modern and enlightened too.

I tried to tell that since 1857 when masses chose to rally under Muslim kings, nawabs and talluqadars and British took vengeance against such Muslim elite, the educated Hindus started hate campaign against Muslims and helped British in their divide and rule policy – all sorts of lies were included in history. No doubt some Muslim rulers were fanatic or under pressure from imported Muslim clergies they coerced people to embrace Islam and imposed Jaziya the large number of Muslim rulers adopted policy of tolerance and it is also true tolerant spiritual Mughal princes – Khusro and Dara had to suffer because of their humane approach but much may be fabrications by Hinduttava and British interpolations in history.

The Hinduttava groups finally organized themselves in form of RSS founded by Dr Hedgewar in 1925. Congress was founded in 1886. Muslim League was founded in 1906 by wealthiest Ismaeli Muslim religious minority Aga Khan. Historians must trace this period from 1857 to 1947.

Hinduttava forces had to relinquish their stand in matter of suttee, child marriage, devdasi, widows remarriage and education of women but they are not ready to surrender their last citadel – caste inequality.

After Independence, they had to agree for Reservations to Dalits for political reasons and possibility of their conversion to Islam or Christianity under banner of Ambedkar – and Buddhism was no problem for them and Ambedkar and some Dalits embraced Buddhism.

After Partition disturbances settled, Muslims remained victims of time to time riots but probably number of Muslims killed to this date is not more than 15000 and perhaps more Muslims had been killed in Bangladesh by Pak army and Jamaate Islami and many times more have been killed by Talibans, Al Qaeda and ISIS.

But what is more painful is reluctance of Police and Administration to provide protection to victims or to help those who are under such threats as happened with Ehsan Jafri MP in Gujarat and government’s inaction on inquiry report from 1947 to this date or giving clean chit to perpetrators of riots by inquiry commissions or setting them free by courts and even assistance and protection and encouragements to rioters and organizers of riots by Police, administration and government as happened in Mumbai and Gujarat and even giving state funeral to architect of Mumbai riots  or bringing the architect of Gujarat riots to the highest post.

But even then, nobody is in reality enemy of Muslims as all these politicians and persons were distressed by execution of Bhutto, arrest of Nawaz Sharif and assassination of Benazir Bhutto. The architect of Mumbai riots was friend of Dilip Kumar and other eminent Muslims and his physician was a Muslim. Once Dilip Kumar opposed agitation against film Fire depicting Lesbianism then this man sent his Sainiks to go in front of Dilip’s residence and perhaps to do sodomy there and then his Sainiks collected there and took off their shirts. This was a teasing of one friend by other.

The architect of Gujarat is now meeting with heads of Muslim States and embracing them and went to Pakistan to have tea with Pak PM.

Mukhtar Abbas Naqvi, Shahnawaz Khan and many Muslims have married daughters of families of top BJP and VHP leaders.

In a party hosted by Sahara, Togadia was already present and as Abdulla Bukhari entered he rushed and embraced him !

Then what is reality ? These anti-Muslim people are in reality hate Backwards and Dalits and fear their dominance and so they raise anti-Muslim bogey and attack a few Muslims to keep Backwards and Dalits in their fold. The educated Dalits are more politically awakened and they are slipping away from their grips. The Backwards are not politically awakened to such an extent and have Muslim phobia and Dalit phobia and are unable to understand real situation. The architects of Mumbai and Gujarat both belong to Backwards section and are loyal to Manuvadis – they accept superiority of Sawarns and feel obliged with welcome gestures from them but are unable to give same welcome gesture to Dalits.

The Reservations are eye sore of Sawarns and this time they could succeed in bringing some Backwards and Dalits to power who may oblige them by terminating Reservations. This is Manuvadis latest political game.

The reality is whatever be their religion, 15 % in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh are same ruling elite and 85 % are backwards and oppressed who are incited to fight and remain divided.   

Responsibilities of educated Muslims 12

  The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

Since 1947, India has become play ground of two evil factors :

1. Conspiracies by Hinduttava elements

2. Muslim orthodoxy and fanaticism

Both are reinforcing each other but both factors may make both communities modern and enlightened too.

Hinduttava group believes in Mien Kampf and is blind follower of Hitler and Goebbels. So they cannot live without hatching conspiracies and conducting propaganda against Muslims, Christians, Secularists, Leftists, Nehru family and others.

The method of propaganda were first sermons and then audio tapes and cassettes and now technology has made it more powerful and we have emails, Facebook and WhatsApp to spread poisonous lies.

In childhood, I heard ‘why you also don’t go to Pakistan – all Muslims are Pakistanis!’ and when grown up and went to college, I heard the name ‘katuwa’ for Muslim. And one student said – ‘ek katuwi chhodne par (itney)….. ganga snaan ka punya milta hai’.

In Kumbh melas, other melas, Sadhus roaming and visiting Hindu families, audiotapes continuously running in indigenous medicine tents we may overhear such talks – ‘we have given bali……now we will not give bali…. we will take bali.’ ‘ We are Ramzadey   they are Haramzadey’, “ They do everything opposite to us then we eat through mouth, from where they should eat ? asks the Sadhvi.’

 And in the night before elections, they raise slogan “Musalmanon ke do sthaan – Pakistan ya Qabristan”

The bricks taken from Babri were declared to be fixed into latrine.

The most recent propaganda is what a retired professor of Medical College forwarded on WhatsApp group of doctors :

“For Hindus in distress : VHP help line : first day 85000 calls were received.  If any Muslim boy is harassing any Hindu girl : a team of 30000 Hindus is ready to help any Hindu within 24 hours.

Numbers are 020 668 03300     075 886 82181

To declare cow as ‘mother of nation ‘  dial toll free no 08554080747”

If Muslim boys are harassing Hindi girl then is it a problem that cannot be solved by normal law and order ? A team of 30000 is required ? Actually in non-BJP ruled states they want to spread sense of insecurity and a perception that non-BJP ruled states are actually Pakistans.

The Dalit girls and Tribal and NE states girls are molested by same Hinduttava people. The Hindu brides are burnt for dowry by Hindu husbands and families.

The Muslim and Hindu girls elope with their lovers. When families and communities take the issue and couple are caught – the boy is sent to jail and girl is sent to nari bandi niketan. The boy may get released on bail, by court or after serving the sentence but poor girl languishes in women protection home and many such girls become insane.

Responsibilities of educated Muslims 11

  The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

Since 1947, India has become play ground of two evil factors :

1. Conspiracies by Hinduttava elements

2. Muslim orthodoxy and fanaticism

Both are reinforcing each other but both factors may make both communities modern and enlightened too.

Hinduttava conspiracy started with hate campaign against Gandhi- the buddha , old man,  who is giving everything to Muslims and Pakistan and is harming Hindus and Hinduism. Educated Middle class families used to say openly ‘why anybody does not kill this buddha ?  Nathuram believed that Hindus will worship him as savior of Hindus and Hinduism. He got himself circumcised. In his third attempt he succeeded by pretending to touch feet of Gandhi and shot him thrice and then ran away trampling upon the pages of Gita fallen from hands of Gandhi. Whole crowd was dumbstruck and turned stone. Some foreign army officer caught him and then Nathuram pretended as Muslim. The riots has erupted all over India, Muslim houses were targeted. Hinduttava camps celebrated and distributed sweets. His identity has been exposed that he was a Brahman but Nehru remained silent. Patel was home minister, he rushed to All India Radio and announced one mad Brahman youth has killed Bapu. ( This account was written by Vikram Rao in The Pioneer ).

Since then Jan sangh used to incite riots and Muslims used to respond fanatically after every provocation and used to fight Police and PAC and used to suffer in Police/ PAC action. It was believed that one Muslim is able to defeat 10 Hindus and foolish Muslims used to attack members of Backwards and Dalits thus increasing their enemies. Then tally used to be done and if more Hindus were killed then in some other place under suitable DM and SP the revenge was taken. The reports of every inquiry commission remained under cold storage and Congress never punished any initiator or perpetrator of riots. Some major riots occurred as in Assam, Mumbai and Gujarat but Congress did nothing to punish the culprits.

The Muslims were living in their poverty and backwardness. The Middle East opened its doors to Asian workers then economic conditions improved but along with it religious orthodoxy escalated and Muslims started obstructing traffic during Friday prayers, started tableegh going village to village and raised big and high mosques. This all generated further hate against Muslims.

Then in Shah Bano case, clergies took the stand that Supreme Court has no authority to interpret Shariah and Muslims came on the roads. Rajiv Gandhi and his associates retaliated by getting locks of Babri opened and started shilanyas for construction of Ram Mandir.

This was hijacked by BJP and LK Advani took out his rath yatra along with trail of riots and communalization of rural folks.

Finally Babri was demolished in 1992 with Congress government at Centre and BJP government in UP.

Months before that, a team of high officers from Delhi visited Ayodhya and my senior colleague Dr SC Srivastava who was friend to someone among them also went and told me later that there they said anyone who wants to see this mosque see it for last time it will not last long.

It is also suspected that pulling down of domes of mosque were rehearsed and actually carried out by trained personnel- in service or ex-servicemen.

Then it was feared that Muslims may become riotous so to thwart them Shiv Sena organized aartis in different areas and got Muslim houses attacked all under Congress government. There was no hope of any succor. At this juncture, some Muslims conducted serial blasts in Mumbai killing several hundred innocent people and this stopped those attacks.

 Many suspects, some innocent, were arrested and languishing in jails and one Yakoob Menon was hanged recently but equally responsible and initiator of violence was not touched and was given State funeral perhaps by Congress CM. Two innocent girls –one Muslim who commented and her Hindu friend who liked her comment against Mumbai Bandh on his death were arrested and sent to jail.

One Afzal Guru who was trained as terrorist in Pakistan but caught and who has left the wrong path was harassed and coerced to arrange car for some planned attack by some pro-Hinduttava security personnel. It is said that there is a hub perhaps at Dubai from where terrorists may be hired. The human children from any family may be stolen and trained as fidayeens by Muslims or CIA or Mossad or Hinduttava trainers. Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee and leader of Opposition Sonia Gandhi were requested to reach Parliament late on that eventful day and fidayeen attack was conducted. Then same Afzal Guru was caught and recently hanged during Congress rule – he was hanged very hurriedly and family was not informed perhaps it was feared that at last moment he may disclose the truth and may have been silent till that date because promised to get released if kept silence.

After its break up in 1965, Pakistan felt itself justified in promoting secessionist activities in Kashmir. Then after demolition of Babri in 1992, Pak sponsored terrorist attacks took place in several places.

But Hinduttava group having distorted perceptions and in love of Hitler and Goebbels thought it wise to conduct terrorist attacks in their own Rashtra to falsely implicate Muslims and to malign Muslims and Islam. Many innocent Muslims were arrested and are still languishing in jails.

Thanks to Shaheed Hemant Karkarey and his two colleagues role of these Hindu terrorists came to light and a few of them like Colonel Purohit and Sadhvi were arrested. Of course, they will be saved some day and get released. And we don’t want death penalty to anyone and understand their follies as they were blinded by Hinduttava ideology and love for Mien Kampf.

Earlier all terrorist attacks were called Islamic or Muslim terrorism but exposure of Hindu terrorism enraged Hinduttava group and LK Advani openly threatened those who are talking of Hindu terrorism. Then after a week of this threat, Mumbai attack was executed.

Most possibly this was done by hired terrorists who knew nothing except did what was ordered to them. The Hotel Taj was attacked and few rooms were destroyed.  It is mode of intelligence people and their likes that they book rooms in hotels in different parts of country and time to time stay there and keep their documents there. Perhaps Karkarey and his colleagues had stayed and kept all evidences in those rooms destroyed by those fidayeens. One Ajmal Kasab was caught alive and was hanged later.

On that very occasion, Hemant Karkarey and his two colleagues were ordered to reach some place perhaps by Union Home Minister or State CM or Home Minister and perhaps they were asked to report in civil uniform without bullet proof jackets. They were ambushed at that spot and killed. Thus men and evidences against Hindu terrorism were destroyed by a great conspiracy.

Responsibilities of educated Muslims 10

  The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

It appears to me that as Muslims were allowed to stay in India, the Dalits were allowed to stay in two Pakistans – the reason for this to get dirty jobs done by these Dalits. Dalits whether converted to Islam or to Christianity remained Dalits in India and in two Pakistans. There is a good movie ‘Ramchandra Pakistani’.

The Christians are being targeted in Pakistan on pretext of blasphemy. Here in India, Christian missionaries are targeted because of their work in tribal area. The Hinduttava brigade wants Dalits and Tribal in its fold to maintain majority status.

In India, there are hardly 5 % people who are Bhakts or Manuvadi and it is they who hatch conspiracies to target other communities. The 95 % need to be united to bring about peace and tranquility in India. For that different sections of 95  % must agree on some essential policies :

1. The religion should be private affair and must be practiced peacefully.

2. No attempt should be made to convert anyone through greed or coercion.

3. Muslims should not listen to Bukharis and Owaisis.

4. Maulvis should keep them confined to religious matters within mosques.

5. Different castes should intermarry and have social interactions and eating together.

6. Education and health care should reach remotest places.

Foremost is the acceptance of Truth, whether through Religion or through Science that “All human beings are EQUAL”.

Responsibilities of educated Muslims 9

  The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

Under British and European education, a section of Muslim and Hindu elite became progressive and Marxist. But all this was fake.

Tilak started his nationalist career by opposing anti-cholera and anti-epidemic measures taken by British as intervention in his religion.

M.K. Gandhi opposed universal education by taking the plea farmers don’t need school education. Even in his time farmers in Europe and Russia were adopting newer techniques not possible without education. The farmers befooled for centuries by money lenders could be saved by banking and insurance. Even today, farmers are committing suicide because they are not able to avail protection of law because they are not educated enough and Bapu/ Father of Nation opposed universal education of farmers, implying that of low caste and he was protagonist of caste system. Historians owe responsibility to expose retrogressive thinking and beliefs of those leaders from 1857 to 1947.

So, the same section of 15% that was orthodox and believer in Caste inequality had donned the mask of nationalism, modernism, enlightenment and Marxism.

There can be no true modernism, enlightenment and Marxism without liberation of women and annihilation of Castes. Same happened in Pakistan and Bangladesh.

Whatever be their religion in India, Pakistan and Bangladesh, the 15 % are socio-economically exploiting the rest of 85 % who are backwards and oppressed.

Responsibilities of educated Muslims 8

  The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

The historians must answer why there was no 1857 like rebellion against 800 years of Muslim dominance and why it was so widespread against British in 1857 ?

The 4000 years of social inequality  and exploitation and all inhuman practices like suttee, devdasi, child marriage, exclusion of widows and even child sacrifice continued unhindered under protection of Muslim rulers.

The British intervened and so rebellion was hatched against them through conspiracy and propaganda as we still see in practices of Sanghis : Muslims were told new cartridge to be opened by chewing contains pork fat and Hindus were told it contains beef pork.

The masses rebelled mostly under leadership of Muslim elite – kings, nawabs, landlords and under some such Hindu elite. At this crucial juncture, many Muslim elite were betrayed by Hindu elite who switched their loyalties to British. This aspect of rebellion must be studied by Historians.

Finally British won and themselves or counseled by Hindu wise groups found Muslims main guilty. In consequence, large number of Muslim elite were hanged.

In this aftermath, persons like Sir Syed thought it proper not to confront British and advance in education and he opposed Muslims joining Congress.

The Hinduttava section emerged that thought if British left and power went back to Muslims it will be worse and so those among them who were once against British returned to Hinduttava fold and spread hate propaganda against Muslims and finally Sangh was born.

Jinnah was secular and nationalist and was not religious- he married a Parsi lady, lived like an English man and ate pork and drank.

The Hinduttava hate campaign and same feelings he sniffed in many Congressmen and he feared the fate of community under Hinduttava dominance.

He demanded Pakistan but no one had any forethought of separate country – everyone thought of Muslim autonomous state under one united country and therefore East and West two provinces were thought of.

Jinnah was responsible for his call of Direct Action Day – it was failure of some naïve person surrounded by cunning friends in Congress and British government. The Hinduttava elements thought it better to exclude Muslim leadership and so country was partitioned with its horror and Jinnah said Pakistan was his blunder. His secularism was killed before his eyes in Pakistan that turned into a military fascist state with Punjabi Sunni dominance where no other people – Hindus, Christians, Ahmadiyas, Shias are safe while architect of Pakistan himself was Ismaeli Shia . The ruling Punjabi Sunni elite is using tribal against minorities as Hinduttava brigade in India is using a section of backwards in form of Shv Sainiks, Bajrang Dal and Ram Sena against minorities and secular people in India.

Responsibilities of educated Muslims 7

  The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

Unfortunately, India is a land of social inequality for last 5000 years. The jobs were made dirty and clean and human beings doing such jobs became dirty or clean and this was made hereditary and socially segregated groups where eating together and intermarrying within groups was not possible because nobody wants to eat together or intermarry with a person or in a family of lower caste.

Muslims came with teaching of one God and belief in whole mankind a progeny of Adam and Eve but succumbed to Brahmanical caste system and did nothing to abolish untouchability, caste inequality, suttee and child marriage and inhuman horrible customs like child sacrifice or forced bosom nudity of low caste women or custom of devdasi.

It is British who took humanitarian measures abolished all those inhuman things and introduced widow remarriage and started education of women and made everyone equal before law.

Now think who were on path of humanity – Muslims in their 800 years or British in their 200 years ?

Nobody rebelled against Muslim rule because status quo of 4000 years continued but British measures of equal law enraged 15 % privileged section and they incited masses to rebel against British in 1857.

Following is the excerpt from speech of Prince Birjis Qadr son of Begum Hazrat Mahal :

:”.......Men of high class whether Muslim belonging to Sayyid, Shaikh, Mughal or Pathan families or Brahmans, Kshatriya, Vaish and Kayastha  among the Hindus were held in esteem and honour in accordance of their position. No mean person for example sweeper, leather worker carder or Pasi could claim equality with them. .........(English) They have brought the honour of the high classes on a level with that of the lower people- sweepers and leather workers. In fact , the English show preference to the lower castes over the higher classes. On the complaint of a sweeper or leather worker, they seize the person of even a Nawab and a Raja and disgrace him. Wherever they go they hang men of high classes, and kill their wives and children. Their soldiers dishonour women. They dig up their houses, seize their property, and leave nothing.” [History of Freedom Movement of India by Tara Chand ]

Responsibilities of educated Muslims 6

  The educated Muslims have historical responsibility at this crucial juncture. The Muslim community has been failed by clergies and communal leaders who pushed the community to the wall and made it vulnerable to attacks by paranoid elements.

We human beings become victim of circumstances or ideology and sometimes are carried too far by our Ideals and thus we become unlawful or inhuman in eyes of State or Society but in reality we were not so.

The Laws, Courts, Police, Intelligence or Army do their jobs but sometimes they do what should not have been done – a Healing Touch is required therefore Kings, Queens and Presidents have power to overrule what should not be done.

In current situation, we have examples of Sanjay Dutt, Colonel Purohit, Sadhvi Pragya and of Maya Kodnani.

The circumstances are such that Under World and Bollywood are very close to each other along with Shiv Sena. This closeness took lives of Divya Bharti, Gulshan Kumar and Sanjay was arrested for possessing some weapon given to him by some friend in Bollywood.

India suffered terrorist attacks in hands of Pak sponsored terrorism. Some Hinduttava organization decided to do similar attacks to teach lessons to Muslims or to pro-Muslim pseudosecular government thus they got blinded by their ideology and themselves went against law, humanity and nation.

Godhra train bogies carrying Karsewaks got fire killing about 60 innocent persons. This was interpreted as done by Muslims and so teach lessons to Muslims the State government got blinded by ideology and orchestrated riots and one minister a woman and a lady doctor Maya Kodnani herself led the mob of killers, arsonists and rapists.

Such people did crimes against humanity and nation and they are not going to be hanged because they belong to majority community and of course nobody should be hanged and each case must be studied by psychologists and sociologists and persons must be dealt with mercifully and rehabilitated if they are no more danger to society.

The circumstances during last phase of British rule were such that some youths turned revolutionaries. Bhagat Singh and his companions are said to have killed Sanders and threw a bomb in assembly. They were hanged and it was expected that if Gandhi had pleaded their lives had been saved but Gandhi did not plead because perhaps all Indian politicians thought it better that they be executed. Mysterious things happened with Subhash Chandra Bose. Chandra Shekhar Azad when surrounded by police he came to Nehru in Anand Bhawan to seek his help but Nehru did not oblige and so Azad returned and shot himself dead. For revolutionary activities, some youths robbed train carrying treasury at Kakori, they were caught and hanged.

 All these persons were carried far by their Ideals. There should have been mercy to them.